When you’re a self-published author, visibility is everything. You can write the most compelling, beautifully edited story in the world—but if no one sees it, it might as well not exist. That’s the heartbreaking reality of indie publishing. So when I first heard about Reedsy Discovery, it sounded like a promising opportunity to get my books in front of real readers, maybe even earn an editorial review I could feature on Amazon or my website.
I decided to give it a try with two of my books—In Articulo Mortis (Book 1 of the Mortis series) and The Shattering (Book 1 of the Silent Era trilogy). For $50 USD per book, Reedsy would place each title into a pool of “certified reviewers” who could choose to review my book, rate it, and potentially spotlight it on the Discovery platform.
It sounded professional. Legitimate. Even exciting.
Unfortunately, my experience turned out to be… well, less than stellar.
The Reedsy Halo Effect
Before I dive into the details, let’s talk about Reedsy itself. If you’ve been in the indie author space for a while, you’ve probably heard of them. They position themselves as the professional publishing hub—a one-stop shop where authors can find editors, designers, formatters, marketers, and more. Their tone often implies that if you’re not using their vetted experts, you’re not doing publishing “the right way.” That rubbed me the wrong way immediately.
It’s not that I don’t value professionalism or quality—far from it. But I’ve been writing and publishing long enough to know that great editors and designers exist outside of any gated platform, and I don’t need someone else to tell me who’s worthy. The implication that authors are somehow “lesser” if they don’t use Reedsy’s handpicked network felt, frankly, arrogant.
Still, I wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt. Maybe Discovery was different—maybe this was a chance to connect with real readers who were passionate about indie books. So, I pushed forward and gave it a try.
Submitting The Shattering and My First Red Flag
The first book I submitted to Reedsy Discovery was The Shattering, the opening novel in my Silent Era trilogy. I filled out the form, uploaded my manuscript, paid the $50, and waited for a reviewer to select it. Eventually, one did.
The resulting review was rated three stars—which, to be fair, isn’t a bad thing on Reedsy. Their rating system is more like Goodreads than Amazon. A three-star rating is still good. So I wasn’t upset about the number. I know not every reader will love my work, and I respect that.
What bothered me was the quality of the review itself.
It read more like a book summary than a thoughtful critique. Paragraphs of plot recap with only a few vague sentences of actual opinion sprinkled in. Worse—and this was the kicker—the reviewer spelled one of my main characters’ names wrong. Not once, but twice. And it wasn’t even a typo. It was an entirely different name.
To add insult to injury, the review was riddled with its own typos and grammatical errors. I remember sitting there staring at the screen, thinking: This is what I paid $50 for?
How was I supposed to use this as an “editorial review” when the reviewer didn’t even take the time to get a character’s name right? If I were to post that on my Amazon page, it would make me look unprofessional, not the reviewer.
Needless to say, that review never made it anywhere near my Amazon listing.
Giving Reedsy a Second Chance
Despite my disappointment, I decided to give Reedsy another chance. Maybe the first reviewer was an anomaly. Maybe I’d just gotten unlucky. So I submitted another title—In Articulo Mortis (Book 1 of the Mortis series)—for review.
This time, things went a little better. I don’t remember whether it received three or four stars, but at least the review was proofread and professional. It wasn’t life-changing, but it wasn’t embarrassing either. I actually included that one on my Amazon page for a time.
But the real problem wasn’t the review itself. It came afterward.
The Aftermath: My Inbox Turned Into a Spam Magnet
Shortly after my books went live on Reedsy Discovery, my inbox started to fill up. At first, I thought, Wow! Maybe people are discovering my book! They weren’t.
Instead, I began receiving a flood of emails from “expert digital marketers” (just like the ones who used to hound me on LinkedIn) claiming they could skyrocket my book sales, build my author brand, and make me the next Hugh Howey… for a small fee, of course.
These weren’t professional proposals. They were cookie-cutter, AI-written spam messages—the kind you can spot a mile away if you’ve ever used ChatGPT. I could practically hear the generic prompts: “Write a persuasive email to an author offering book marketing services.” And many of them were littered with the tell-tale emojis.
Every email sounded the same. They had taken my story blurb as well as my author bio from my website and plugged it into ChatGPT in an effort to sound like they gave a damn. I guess they didn’t realize that everyone else in my inbox was using the same tactic.
Every sender claimed to have years of experience, yet almost none of them had an actual website or portfolio to back it up.
One person did include a website link, but their email address didn’t match the domain in their signature or the site they linked to. That’s a massive red flag in any industry, but especially in marketing. If someone can’t even manage consistent branding between their name, email, and supposed business, how can they possibly manage yours?
It didn’t take long for me to realize what was happening:
Reedsy Discovery had essentially turned my author contact info into a target list for scammers preying on self-published authors.
Why Real Experts Don’t Cold-Call You
Here’s the thing: legitimate marketers don’t cold-email random indie authors asking for work.
Real professionals have a proven track record, testimonials, case studies, and a visible online authority. Their content speaks for them. Their results attract clients naturally through reputation, referrals, or inbound marketing.
When someone has to beg for your business out of nowhere, it’s often because they don’t have any real clients to showcase. That’s not to say every unsolicited message is automatically a scam, but when 90% of them sound identical and contain the same vague promises, it’s not hard to see the pattern.
And unfortunately, Reedsy Discovery seems to have become a hunting ground for these “marketers.” Authors join the platform hoping to gain visibility, but instead, they gain inbox noise. It’s disheartening, especially for writers who may not yet recognize the warning signs.
What I Learned (and What I’d Do Differently)
If I could go back and give myself advice before submitting to Reedsy Discovery, I’d say this:
- Don’t assume every platform is author-first.
Reedsy is a business, and its goal is to make money, not necessarily to make you successful. That’s fine, but it’s important to go in with your eyes open. - A paid review doesn’t guarantee a quality review.
You might get lucky and connect with someone who truly understands your work. But you might also end up with a “certified” reviewer who skims your book, summarizes the plot, and calls it a day. - Protect your contact information.
Use a separate email address for submissions or public listings. That way, when the spam starts rolling in, it won’t clog your main inbox. (I used my website’s email, but it’s still a pain, so now I block almost anyone who emails me soliciting services.) - Vet anyone who reaches out.
Always research names, emails, and websites. If the email and website don’t match, or if the person can’t show actual results, walk away. - Remember: visibility and credibility aren’t the same.
Paying for a slot on a discovery platform might make you visible for a moment, but true credibility is built over time through consistent quality, authentic engagement, and real reader connection.
So… Is Reedsy Discovery Worth It?
In my opinion? No.
At least, not for what I wanted. I went in hoping for a boost in visibility and a chance to connect with genuine readers. What I got instead was a mediocre review, a spam-filled inbox, and a deeper appreciation for doing things the slow, authentic way.
That’s not to say no one has ever benefited from Reedsy Discovery. I’m sure some authors have. But if you’re considering it, know that you’re not paying for guaranteed exposure or thoughtful critique. You’re paying for the chance that someone might read your book, and even then, the outcome can be hit or miss.
Final Thoughts
Indie publishing is already a vulnerable endeavor. We pour our hearts, time, and money into our work, so it stings when a platform that promises to help authors succeed ends up feeling more like a vanity showcase for its own ecosystem.
Reedsy Discovery wasn’t a total loss for me; it was a learning experience. It reminded me that not every professional-looking service truly serves authors, and that discernment is just as valuable a skill as writing itself.
If you’re an indie author looking to build real traction, skip the middlemen. Focus on building your reader community directly—through newsletters, social media authenticity, collaborations, and consistent publishing.
It takes longer. It’s harder. But the trust you build along the way? That’s worth far more than a $50 “certified” editorial review.
Thank you for reading.
-Eliza
Want more? Social Media is always the last to hear anything. Subscribe to get ahead of the curve and receive announcements on new publications, events, posts, and more. Because I don’t believe in digital clutter, I promise not to flood your inbox! As a bonus, receive 5 free short stories when you sign up.